My love of Shameless is well known. It was my favorite new show of last year, and it’s second season is proving nearly as entertaining. Homeland was amazing. House of Lies, Showtime’s new vehicle with Don Cheadle, has been spectacular so far this year. Dexter was groundbreaking a few years ago, and still remains a guilty pleasure akin to eating Peanut Butter M&Ms at 1am. Californication, Weeds, and a host of second tier shows are still quality television. So, I’m beginning to wonder – is Showtime supplanting HBO as the best cable content provider?
HBO has the best reputation, and there’s a reason for that. HBO was the first content provider to really embrace the long-form story telling that defines these great shows. With The Sopranos and The Wire (two of the greatest shows ever to grace the airwaves), story lines arched across seasons. They redefined the medium, showing everyone else that TV didn’t have to be about 30 minute self-contained sitcoms or soap opera dramas. HBO proved that TV, not the movies, is really the place to build an intelligent drama. HBO redefined the medium, and they’ve got a veritable Mount Rushmore of original content – The Sopranos, The Wire, Deadwood, Boardwalk Empire, Band of Brothers, and Six Feet Under just to name a few. But, as always, the question is, “What have you done for me lately?” Boardwalk Empire’s encore season was terrific, exceeding every expectation. Game of Thrones showed promise, but definitely is a genre with more limited appeal. True Blood is a teen soap opera with vampires. Curb Your Enthusiasm is fun, but predictably formulaic. I love Eastbound and Down, but it only appears on the schedule sporadically and this season is officially its last. I’m not a fan of Treme at all, and Luck hasn’t yet sucked me in.
Soooo… Today, if you had the money to spend on only one movie channel, and you had to pick between Showtime and HBO based on original programming, who would you go with? Personally – I think I may lean towards Showtime. I’d miss Boardwalk Empire a lot, and I’d miss Game of Thrones a little. Other than that? I don’t think I’d miss that much. What about you?